| re: 3 Bats Live DVD | |
|
Posted by: |
MichaelMP 11:22 am UTC 10/18/07 |
| In reply to: | re: 3 Bats Live DVD - Pudding 09:19 pm UTC 10/16/07 |
| Pudding, I have respect for your role in Steinworld. And I love your sometimes sarcastic humour. But I dislike when you judge things you donīt know about. Like the album you had not bought (Bat 3), the DVD you have not seen yet (3 Bats Live) or the variations of shows, when you never attended several in a row. If you would ever have seen Meat Loaf concerts in a row you would have experienced how special things change from night to night (which admittedly includes his voice). I. e. the duration of songs like Frying Pan, Objects and RnR Dreams vary massively because of Meats improvisations or variations (or whatever we may call them). Its a reall task for the band to follow his path. And these improvisations/variations usually offer new, non-album parts of the songs! Which to me is an addition and not unfaithfull to Jims genius songwriting. Frequently attending rock concerts i can say that with Meat there is much more variation and much less dubbing and samples than usual these days. Its art happening live on stage! MichaelMP > > I'm still unclear as to what constitutes improvising. > > Making up lyrics, or just finding different ways of > > singing the original ones. I guess it may be up to the > > listener. > > To improvise is, 'To compose, recite, sing, etc., > without previous preparation' > > So if Meat decided to all of a sudden sing Paradise with > just a banjo, then that would be improvising. If he > decided to all of a sudden sing Heaven Can Wait with just > a guitar, then that would be improvising. But to say FUCK > 18 times instead of 12 during a song isn't really > improvising. And since MEat Loaf's setlists are pretty > much set in stone, there's not much room for improvising, > otherwise Meat would get confused. > > Perhaps some people are misinterpretting Meat's onstage > moments of confusion with improvising. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: 3 Bats Live DVD - Pudding 09:19 pm UTC 10/16/07 |
| Next: | re: 3 Bats Live DVD - Willis 11:35 pm UTC 10/16/07 |
| Thread: | |