Not a logistical problem, but a question sure....anyone who sings, has a octaval range that is measured on a semi-regular basis. The more practised a singer is, presuming that they work on their upper and lower octaves, strengthen the dimensions of their singable range. Most professional singers tout that they have something like a five octave range. In the vocal classifications, there are ranges of capability that are approachable to one more than the other, and tonal differences along with those. A tenor cannot be mistaken for a baritone, even though they may be both able to sing a same note in a same octave. But a tenor can reach a certain range high, and a certain range low.
Logistically, Jim has reached the notes of those songs, and did reach the notes of those songs, and recorded himself doing so in the performances on Bad For Good, all the songs on that album, and other songs that he did not need to credit another singer to, like "A Kiss Is A Terrible Thing To Waste" (not the metal version of course), and "Not Allowed To Love".
Love your Jimmy!
> > The question isn't whether Jim could reach notes,
> > it is whether Jim did reach them.
>
> Minor logistical problem here ... if he couldn't,
> then it follows that he didn't. So it most
> certainly is a valid question and one that cannot be
> ignored.
>
> Dave
|
