| re: NJC The art and craft of...Desmond Child | |
|
Posted by: |
Rob 12:55 am UTC 08/07/07 |
| In reply to: | re: NJC The art and craft of...Desmond Child - Leesa 10:44 pm UTC 08/06/07 |
> Hey jerk, > Let's watch how we throw about the 'middle-aged women' > blankets around here. I'll have you know that those of us > Jim fans who were in high school when 'Bat' came out ARE > now middled-aged--I'm one! And no one could despise shit > like Celine Dion or Bab's (I was subjected to her murder > of 'LITD' today at Walgreens--I nearly puked) more than > ME. > And my kids, 16 and 11 yrs, LOVE 'Pandora's Box' and make > me change the same offering's when they come on on 'Bat 2' > because they've become convienced that the Loaf sucks--or > at least didn't do Jim's work (excluding the first Bat > stuff) justice. > What makes you make such sweeping judgement as to > Westlife's market, I don't know. But keep in mind, you're > remarks target Jim's ORIGINAL fans (and their offspring > thusly exsposed) who have keep the faith all these years. > Please rethink your audience. > I love Desmond Child for the most part, and yes, he's much > more formulae than Jim will ever be--but he hasn't a drop > of the POWER Jim possesses as a lyricist. Still, he is a > damned good composer, especially commercially, on alot of > levels. Like everything, sometimes it works, sometimes it > doesn't. > Leesa Well, that told me! ;-) I wasn't actually insinuating that ALL middle aged women and pubescent girls are Westlife fans, rather that most Westlife fans happen to be middle aged women and pubescent girls - there is a difference. However, if I happened to offend you with my post, then of course I apologise. | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: NJC The art and craft of...Desmond Child - Leesa 10:44 pm UTC 08/06/07 |
| Next: | re: NJC The art and craft of...Desmond Child - Bright_Eyes 11:44 pm UTC 08/06/07 |
| Thread: | |