| re: In The Land Of The Pig (Question) | |
|
Posted by: |
2jaxx 07:46 am UTC 03/15/10 |
| In reply to: | In The Land Of The Pig (Question) - RSG 11:02 pm UTC 03/14/10 |
| I actually prefer Meat's version over Rob Evan's because Rob's version is way too theatrical and it doesn't have the urgent feel to it. The rythmic arrangement of the verses doesn't benefit the song. Maybe I just don't like the arrangement of Jim's more recent compositions that are more focused on musical and not rock. The production on Bat III is not perfect, so it still could have been better. > In Meat's recording its very much metal. The piano seems > to be not as distinct as it was in Jim's non guitar demo. > I like the vocals on both recordings but for different > reasons. Meat's growl. And Rob's annunciation. > > My question is, Had Jim produced the recording, of Meat's. > Would it have had the heavy guitar? Anyone like Meat's > recording over Rob Evan's? > > | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | In The Land Of The Pig (Question) - RSG 11:02 pm UTC 03/14/10 |
| Next: | re: In The Land Of The Pig (Question) - Evil_One 10:17 am UTC 03/15/10 |
| Thread: |
|