HOME | MAIN BOARD | TWITTER | LOGIN | REGISTER | SEARCH | FLAT MODE

not logged in

re: Is Lietmotif The Same As A Reprise?

Posted by:
pidunk 07:13 am UTC 05/13/07
In reply to: re: Is Lietmotif The Same As A Reprise? - rockfenris2005 07:02 am UTC 05/13/07


I'm sure you can continue to find reasons to hate me :) But you could like me just as easily. Herman Melville's Moby Dick is about the whale and Gipeto, a presumed death with the continuance of life, which took all the dimensions of every emotion and every permutation of issues concerning life, hope, and second chances. A Mississippi riverboat has a thing or two in thematic common in Jim's universe, which you'd be angry if I tried to explain. But, there is connection, between those two and the piece "Graveyard Shift". Even if in the most literal sense, a graveyard deals with what, but graves (one of the surnames in Jim's genealogy, I have learned, which could be a double entrendre given up by fate in a sense.)


>
> unless Jim's work as a whole was to be viewed as
> > one cohesive piece which is meant to be taken together.

Yes, I do believe that Jim's works are particles of one whole.

I
> > think that would be an incredible stretch of the
> > definition of LietMotif, tho.

Perhaps, but that is the artistic domain.


>
> I agree. I see no theme behind i.e. using the same tune of
> "Edging Into Darkness" for "The Graveyard Shift". What
> does Batman have to do with Herman Melville and a
> Mississippi riverboat? Nothing.

Maybe Batman as a comic character has nothing to do with those, but I think that study of Jim's works could yield to the understanding that he does not mold to the story, but makes the story mold to his own vision.




reply |

Previous: re: Is Lietmotif The Same As A Reprise? - rockfenris2005 07:02 am UTC 05/13/07
Next: re: Is Lietmotif The Same As A Reprise? - Smeghead 08:59 pm UTC 05/13/07

Thread:



HOME | MAIN BOARD | LOG OFF | START A NEW THREAD | EDIT PROFILE | SEARCH | FLAT MODE