| re: The ULTIMATE Steinman "what-if" IMO is... |
|
Posted by:
 |
Pudding 10:04 am UTC 07/30/07 |
| In reply to: |
re: The ULTIMATE Steinman "what-if" IMO is... - rockfenris2005 09:50 am UTC 07/30/07 |
|
> I think it would be. Andrew Lloyd Webber was on the top of
> the world at the time. It didn't matter *who* he
> collaborated with, it was going to be a hit.
Of course it matters. ALW and Jim collaborated on WDTW and it wasn't really commercially successful. WDTW spawned ALW's biggest hit and has a fantastic score IMO, so your theory is little out of whack.
> Depends which version you're familiar with.
No it doesn't. You compared Tanz to Jekyll & Hyde's run on Broadway, so that's the show that can only be used as a comparison, and that's the version that's crap. If the alternate version has the same songs in it, then that would be crap too. The songs in Jekyll & Hyde to me are shit.
|
|
|
|
reply |
|
|
| Previous: |
re: The ULTIMATE Steinman "what-if" IMO is... - rockfenris2005 09:50 am UTC 07/30/07 |
| Next: |
re: The ULTIMATE Steinman "what-if" IMO is... - rockfenris2005 10:28 am UTC 07/30/07 |
|
| Thread: |
|