| Let's play Sophie's Choice...Bat of BFG? | |
|
Posted by: |
Jacqueline 08:38 am UTC 05/19/07 |
| In reply to: | Bat vs BfG - Wilbury 05:50 am UTC 05/19/07 |
| I'm very glad for any recording of Jim singing his own songs and I love BFG. That said, if I had to make "Sophie's Choice" between the two...Bat stays with me. No crying (out loud) about it...I'd pick Bat. :) Everyone else? > Hey all. > > I don't mean to do the poll thing, and ask lame questions > just to incite lame discussion, but here's a real quick > (lame) question that I'm legitimately interested to hear > the answers of: > > Does anyone here significantly prefer Bat over BfG, or > vice versa? > > It's just hit me, going thru and cleaning up my albums / > books etc, that I find Bad For Good waaayyyyy more > interesting than Bat out of Hell. Be it thru over exposure > of Bat or not I dunno, but Bad For Good is more > interesting to me in pretty much every way: tracklist, > album cover, free EP :o) , orchestral pieces, deeper pool > of musicians, sonic quality in general. > > I don't like Karla DeVito from the live recordings all > that much, but she's great on Dance in my Pants. And it's > good to have the variation. > > Is this opinion shared by others here? or is Bat too > strong to pass? | |
| reply | | |
| Previous: | re: Now that I mention Jim and Meat re-doing BooH... - rockfenris2005 10:29 am UTC 05/19/07 |
| Next: | re: Let's play Sophie's Choice...Bat of BFG? - Klasien 09:37 am UTC 05/19/07 |
| Thread: |
|